Tuesday, November 27, 2012

Looking Back (Hypertext Blog Reflection)


This was not the first blog I have had to do as a class assignment.  I was required to do one for my ninth-grade English class.  We had to write things like our own eulogy.  This blog had a completely different purpose.  This blog was about reflecting on a text and our class discussion.  Admittedly, I love discussion-based classes.  I am an opinionated person; I also have a talkative nature.  These two things make this blog a perfect exercise for me.  I am able to express the opinions I had that did not fit into the discussion or that I realized after the class, and I am also able to deeply analyze the text.  When I have an interesting or relevant thought and no one to share it with, it frustrates me.  This blog was an outlet for that frustration.  

I really settle in to the process of analyzing the text with Passion, the close-reading blog.  I used the formula of close-reading to develop an understanding of the film Girl, Interrupted that I might not have come up with otherwise.  Going step-by-step to find a deeper conclusion helped me understand what the goal of this blog was.  It made it easier to do such analysis in the first essay, in my future blog posts, and in my mind as we were looking at different texts.

I had never really been to a lecture before, at least not one like the Christians Culture Lecture.  Responding to such a lecture was even more foreign to me.  Yet, in Faith and Religion, I connected James Carroll’s lecture to my other classes.  For weeks, I had had all the connections between my different classes running through my head.  I had been talking about religion in nearly all my classes.  This lecture and this blog helped me express those connections and make a conclusion based on those connections.  I pick up on one point of Carroll’s, six of his words, and on knowledge I had gained from my different classes.  Then, I used all those different aspects to develop a deep and meaningful conclusion. 


HeLa without Henrietta reflected on something that came up during our class discussion.  Someone had mentioned that you had to include HeLa cells in Henrietta’s story but you did not have to include Henrietta in the story of HeLa cells.  This struck a cord with me, so I used this blog to further reflect on the statement.  Ultimately, I sought to prove my peer’s statement true.  I did this by telling the story of Henrietta and telling the story of the HeLa cells.


Karma was both a reaction to class discussion and a realization of a valuable insight after class.  We had been talking in class about how Max was being selfish by not being completely honest with Clara.  After class, I was looking through the text again and found the where he says that he does not care about Clara’s feelings, that it was his story and his life.  This fit perfectly with our class discussion.  So, I used this blog to share something, if only to air, that I realized post-class.  I also furthered a topic from our discussion.


In Truth, I take on philosophy, or at least as much as I am capable of.  I ask the reader questions, and I ask myself questions.  I force myself to think harder and more deeply than I have done in a long time if ever before.  That is the purpose of this blog.  To get me and anyone who reads it to think.  This post most certainly achieves that.  

The blog achieved its purpose.  It got me to think about the text outside of class, forced me to delve deeper into the text, allowed me to share things I realized after class, and provided more space to share my opinions about things.  It made my class experience more fulfilling and helped me comprehend and digest our class texts.  

If I had to start at the beginning of the semester, knowing what I know now, I might have done in my earlier blogs what I did in my later ones.  I looked deeper into the texts.  I drew from class discussions.  Both these things and more made my posts more meaningful.  The earlier posts could have been improved by doing this.  



Truth (Lives and Times #13)


In Power, Ama asks Omishto this question:

What do you know and what do you just believe? (67)

Knowledge is defined as “facts, information, and skills acquired by a person through experience or education.”  Fact is defined as “a thing that is indisputably the case.”  Indisputable is defined as “unable to be challenged or denied.”

Yet, can’t everything be challenged?  I may see a glass of water spill right in front of me, but someone two cities away might not.  To me, that the water spilled is a fact; I know that the water spilled.  The person two cities away, however, could challenge that the water spilled.  Is the water spilling no longer a fact because it is capable of being “challenged or denied.”  

I know that the earth is round.  Scientists tell me (and the world) that this is a fact.  Centuries ago, though, it was a fact that the earth was flat.  People challenged that idea and found and presented evidence that proved it wrong.  Still, having never seen for myself the shape of this planet, how do I know it’s round?  Do I not believe in the scientists?

Belief is defined as “something one accepts as true or real; a firmly held opinion or conviction.”  True is defined as “in accordance with fact or reality.”

So, ultimately, believing something is accepting that it cannot be challenged or denied….even if it can.  

Do we really know anything?  Is anything fact?  Or do we just believe?

Do we know that lightning is electricity?  Or do we believe that lightning is electricity?

And, if we just believe everything without really knowing anything, why do we, as a whole society, accept only some beliefs as truth?  

Why are your beliefs true but mine aren’t?  Why are Christians’ beliefs true, but Muslims’ aren’t?  

We’re back to the spilt water.  My truth is different than the truth of someone two cities away.  I have had different experiences; I have lived a different life.  I have seen the water spill; I have experienced God’s love.  Can I fault someone who hasn’t?

Truth is subjective.

Monday, November 12, 2012

Karma (Lives and Times #12)


The first words of the short story are “He does not write to his wife about….” (17).  The first thing that readers learn about Max is that he is withholding information from Clara.  This withholding happens throughout the entire story.  He does not tell Clara things that he thinks will frighten her.  He tells her neither of his near-death nor of his changing wants and ambitions.  

Eventually, he will withhold everything from her for six months.  He admits that, in remaining silent for so long, he is not thinking about her or what she is going through.  “This is his story, his life unfolding” (65).  He is focusing on himself and the decisions he needs to make.  

When “Servants of the Map” concludes, the readers know that Max has decided to remain in the area for another year instead of returning home to his wife, Clara.  Yet, in his first letter to Clara in six months, he does not write to her of his decision.  “He has kept to much from her, these last months.  If his letters were meant to be a map of his mind, a way for her to follow his trail, then he has failed her” (67).

If Max wrote to Clara of his decision, she would not be understanding.  This is not because she would refuse to; it would be because she would have no knowledge of any of Max’s experiences and feelings that led to his decision.  

In his letters to her, he has described his new knowledge of plants (from reading) and his recording of the plants he sees, but he has not told her of his passion for botany or even that he bought a botany kit.  How could she possibly understand his wanting to stay to observe the growth of plants?

He has hinted in his letters of a change in him and their relationship, but he has not explained the change to her.  He has not detailed his changing emotions.  How could she possibly understand his new love of botany?

Max’s correspondence with Clara began with him withholding “frightening” details from her.  Therefore, when he knows he needs to tell her of his decision, he cannot bring himself to do so, because he knows that she will not understand it.  And that is his own fault.

Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Communication (Lives and Times #11)


Language is defined as “the system of communication used by a particular community or country.”  But is language all there is in communication?

While words and language are a critical part of communication, they are by no means the only parts.  Do we not grasp non-verbal cues given during a face-to-face conversation?  Hand gestures, body positions, voice tone, and more all contribute to our understanding of another person.  

When we receive a text message, do we not wonder sometimes at how we should take it?  Without hearing a tone of voice, how are we to know whether a comment was meant to be sarcastic or mean?

Communication is so much more than language.  There are so many factors when communicating with another person that a shared language, ultimately, is not really necessary to achieve understanding.

By using hand gestures, body language, tone of voice, and facial expressions, a person can understand someone who speaks a different language than him or her.  

Language is important; yet, communication is possible without it.